21 Awkward Questions Atheists Frequently Ask Believers

SharePinEmailReligious belief is a deeply personal and sometimes contentious subject. Atheists often have questions for religious people that stem from curiosity, skepticism, or simply a desire to understand different worldviews. We take a look at 21 thought-provoking questions that atheists commonly ask religious people. How Can Religion Explain Science? The relationship between religion and science…

Religious belief is a deeply personal and sometimes contentious subject. Atheists often have questions for religious people that stem from curiosity, skepticism, or simply a desire to understand different worldviews. We take a look at 21 thought-provoking questions that atheists commonly ask religious people.

How Can Religion Explain Science?

Editorial credit: Kristina Kuptsevich / Shutterstock.

The relationship between religion and science is often scrutinized, with some questioning how religious beliefs reconcile with scientific discoveries that contradict them. The conflict between scientific understanding and religious teachings is one of the most debated subjects in the world, with people on both sides insisting they have the correct view.

Why Would God Punish People?

Editorial credit: Jeremyboer / Wikimedia Commons /CC BY-SA 3.0

The concept of an afterlife, particularly the idea that some people will live eternal punishment for their sins, raises complex ethical questions. Atheists struggle to understand how a just and loving deity can condemn people so harshly for their mistakes. While we all have different beliefs about what happens when we die, non-believers cannot accept there’s a heaven and a hell. 

Why is There Evil in the World?

Editorial credit: rayjunk / Shutterstock.

One of the most common questions from non-believers is how there’s evil and suffering in the world if God has the power to prevent such tragedies. Atheists often ask if a benevolent and all-powerful deity exists, why is there so much suffering and injustice in the world? Religious followers often struggle to explain how God can allow people to go through so much pain. 

Why is Scientific Evidence Ignored?

Editorial credit: Billion Photos/ Shutterstock.

Atheists often ask why faith is valued over scientific and historical evidence in religious contexts. They question how people, particularly the highly educated, can justify their belief in religious doctrines without empirical evidence. Non-believers challenge religious people to explain basic scientific concepts that are often denied in scriptures, such as the existence of dinosaurs.

Can Morality Exist Without God?

Editorial credit: VGstockstudio/ Shutterstock.

Another common question posed to religious followers is about morality. Atheists often argue that ethical behavior does not require belief in a deity and that they can be just as moral without religious beliefs.

Are Miracles and Supernatural Events Natural?

Editorial credit: chayanuphol / Shutterstock.

Atheists are skeptical of miracles and supernatural claims in religious scripture and modern-day life. They question how to distinguish between genuine miracles and natural phenomena. Questioning the credibility of supernatural events reported in religious traditions and asking for evidence behind every event is common among atheists.

Why Are There Multiple Religions?

Editorial credit: 9dream studio / Shutterstock.

Many atheists question the validity of the vast number of religious beliefs worldwide. With an estimated 4000 religions worldwide, according to World Population Review, non-believers ask why one particular religion is considered true while others are not.

Are Ancient Scriptures Historically Accurate?

Editorial credit: Doidam 10 / Shutterstock.

Questions about the historical accuracy of religious texts are common among non-believers. Some feel that they cannot trust ancient scriptures when historical and archaeological evidence sometimes contradicts them. Some religions, such as Catholics, acknowledge such terms but point out evidence that Gospel writers can be trusted to speak reliably about history. 

Does Prayer Work?

Editorial credit: BRAIN2HANDS / Shutterstock.

Atheists often ask followers if they believe prayer actually changes outcomes or if it is a psychological comfort. They ask how effective the power of prayer and divine intervention is, especially when outcomes can usually be explained by natural causes or coincidence.

Why Are There Religious Wars?

Editorial Credit: Stasia04 / Shutterstock.

Throughout history, religion has been a factor in numerous conflicts, which poses questions about why so many wars and acts of violence have religious motivations. The critiques of the role of religion in war have long caused division and conflict among non-believers and believers.

Do You Agree With Religious Views on Gender and Sexuality?

Editorial credit: Ground Picture / Shutterstock.

Many religious doctrines have specific views on gender roles and sexuality, which don’t always align with contemporary views. Atheists want to understand how religious people view gender equality and LGBTQ+ rights, as well as their views on social justice issues. Research by Pew shows that people who know someone personally who is part of the LGBTQ+ community are more tolerant of gay marriage. However, this isn’t the case for many religious people who are strongly against homosexual relationships. 

Why Isn’t Everyone Worthy of Salvation?

Editorial credit: travelview / Shutterstock.

The idea that only followers of a particular religion will attain salvation can be troubling for some. Non-believers ask how can a loving deity exclude billions of people from salvation based on their lack of religious beliefs.

How Can You Ignore Evolution?

Editorial credit: SeventyFour / Shutterstock.

The debate between evolution and creationism remains a significant point of contention. People who are skeptical ask how religious beliefs about creation stand up to the overwhelming scientific evidence for evolution. 

What Role Should Religion Play in Modern Secular Societies?

Editorial credit: Jacqueline F Cooper / Shutterstock.

The role religion should play in modern secular societies is a common question among atheists. Atheists often question whether religious beliefs should influence public policy and education; for example, should there be faith schools, or should all schools be secular, with religion being taught outside of formal education? 

Where is the Evidence of the Divine?

Editorial Credit: Prixel Creative / Shutterstock.

A major question for atheists is, “What constitutes evidence for the existence of a God?” Atheists ask for concrete, empirical evidence of divine existence, challenging religious individuals to substantiate their beliefs beyond personal experience and scripture.

What is Faith?

Editorial credit: fizkes / Shutterstock.

The definition of faith and why it is considered a virtue in many religions is a deep philosophical question that brings up many different answers. This question delves into the nature of faith and why it is seen as a positive trait despite the lack of evidence.

What is a Religious Experience?

Editorial credit: fizkes/ Shutterstock.

One question among those unsure about religion is how to differentiate between genuine religious experiences and psychological or cultural influences. The validity of religious experiences reported by believers cannot truly be proven and is not always subject to scrutiny, leading many atheists to think that religious people simply believe what they want to. 

How Does Your Upbringing Influence Your Beliefs?

Editorial credit: wavebreakmedia / Shutterstock.

It is often debated how much one’s religious beliefs are influenced by upbringing and culture. Atheists often argue that religious beliefs are heavily shaped by the environment in which one is raised, questioning the objectivity of such beliefs.

How Does Free Will Factor Into the Problem of Evil?

Editorial credit: fizkes / Shutterstock.

How does free will factor into the problem of evil? Some theodicies argue that free will is necessary for genuine love and morality, but how does this explain natural disasters and diseases? 

How Can Faith Come Together?

Editorial Credit: PUWADON SANG / Shutterstock.

How can meaningful dialogue occur between different faiths and atheism? This question is raised for those who want to explore the possibilities for constructive conversations that respect differing worldviews while seeking common ground.

How Does Religion Impact Mental Health?

Editorial credit: Nastyaofly / Shutterstock.

What impact does religion have on mental health is a question that many atheists pose to followers. Studies from the National Alliance of Mental Health show mixed results, with some indicating positive effects and others highlighting negative consequences of certain religious beliefs.

20 Catholic Beliefs That Aren’t in the Bible

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

20 Catholic Beliefs That Aren’t in the Bible

18 Outdated Church Traditions That Are Driving People Away

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

18 Outdated Church Traditions That Are Driving People Away

25 Quirks of Catholic Culture That People Struggle To Understand

Editorial credit: KieferPix / Shutterstock.

25 Quirks of Catholic Culture That People Struggle To Understand

Leave a Reply